Vanilla, caramel and hazelnut in full 750 ml bottles with a pump for each, about 53 cents a serving: the easiest way to start flavoring coffee at home.
Approximate — verify the latest price
BrewSift earns a commission on some purchases. It never changes our scores. Why you can trust us
Buy it if
Skip it if
Not for you? Consider the Torani Sugar Free Café Variety 4-Pack — or see all coffee syrups .
The three flavors that go in most café lattes, in Torani's 25.4 fl oz bottles, with three dispensing pumps in the box. Torani sweetens its Original syrups with pure cane sugar; its own vanilla label lists 80 calories and 20 g of added sugar per 2-tablespoon serving. At $39.99 for 75 servings it is not the cheapest syrup per serving on this page, but it is the only listing here that includes pumps, and Torani rates its pump at about a quarter ounce a stroke, so dosing is repeatable from the first cup. Sold by a third-party seller at about the price we list as of 2026-10-21, shipped by Amazon.
Scored across the dimensions that matter for coffee syrups. The overall is a weighted average — see the formula.
The gear that pairs with the Coffee Syrup Variety 3-Pack with Pumps to make a complete, working setup.
A standalone frother adds café-style milk foam for lattes and cappuccinos without a steam wand.
The right cup — a warmed demitasse for espresso, double-wall glass for milk drinks — is a small, satisfying finish to a good setup.
A vacuum-insulated mug keeps your coffee hot for hours and doesn't leak in a bag.
Four full-size sugar-free bottles, caramel, vanilla, hazelnut and chocolate, at about 29 cents a serving: a cheap way to try sugar-free syrup across the core flavors, chocolate included.
Sugar-free caramel, hazelnut, vanilla and toasted marshmallow at about 24 cents a serving, from the brand that says its sugar-free line resists curdling in dairy.
Six full-size sugar-free bottles, including mocha and butter toffee, at about 28 cents a serving: the widest sugar-free spread on this page.
A full 750 ml bottle of sugar-free vanilla for $5.99, about 24 cents a serving: the cheapest way onto this page and the cheapest way to find out whether sucralose suits you.
Jordan's zero-calorie vanilla in a full 25.4 oz bottle for $9.98, about 40 cents a serving: the single-bottle test before buying the six-flavor sampler.