Independent coffee benchmarks · No sponsored winners · Est. MMXXVI
DaVinci Gourmet Sugar Free Traditional Variety 4-Pack
DaVinci Gourmet Researched

Sugar Free Traditional Variety 4-Pack

Sugar-free caramel, hazelnut, vanilla and toasted marshmallow at about 39 cents a serving, from the brand that says its sugar-free line resists curdling in dairy.

Cutting sugarIced and hot drinks
7.9
BrewSift Score
Good
$39.19

Approximate — verify the latest price

BrewSift earns a commission on some purchases. It never changes our scores. Why you can trust us

Should you buy it?

Buy it if

  • Cutting sugar
  • Iced and hot drinks
  • About 39 cents a serving
  • Toasted marshmallow as a fourth flavor

Skip it if

  • No pumps in the box
  • Sucralose-sweetened, the same aftertaste caveat as other sugar-free syrups
  • Slightly dearer per bottle than Torani's sugar-free pack

The verdict

Four 25.4 fl oz bottles: Caramel, Hazelnut, Toasted Marshmallow and Vanilla. The ingredient panels list sucralose as the sweetener, and DaVinci says its sugar-free syrups dissolve easily in hot or cold drinks and resist curdling in dairy. At the price we checked it is about $9.80 a bottle and 39 cents a serving, a little more than Torani's sugar-free four-pack, with toasted marshmallow in place of chocolate.

BrewSift Score breakdown

Scored across the dimensions that matter for coffee syrups. The overall is a weighted average — see the formula.

Flavor7.2
Value per serving9.2
Flavor variety8.0
Pumps & packaging6.8

Pros & cons

What we like

  • About 39 cents a serving
  • Toasted marshmallow as a fourth flavor
  • DaVinci states it dissolves hot or cold and resists curdling in dairy

Watch-outs

  • No pumps in the box
  • Sucralose-sweetened, the same aftertaste caveat as other sugar-free syrups
  • Slightly dearer per bottle than Torani's sugar-free pack

Specifications

Flavors
Caramel, Hazelnut, Toasted Marshmallow, Vanilla
Pack
4 × 25.4 fl oz (750 ml)
Sweetener
Sucralose (ingredient list)
Serving
2 tbsp; 25 per bottle (DaVinci)
Price per serving (at check)
$0.39
Pumps
Not included

Complete your setup

The gear that pairs with the Sugar Free Traditional Variety 4-Pack to make a complete, working setup.

Froth the milk
Maestri House Automatic Milk Frother & Steamer
Maestri House

Automatic Milk Frother & Steamer

A standalone frother adds café-style milk foam for lattes and cappuccinos without a steam wand.

$89.99Buy
Serve it right
Bodum Pavina Double Wall Glasses (Set of 2, 12oz)
Bodum

Pavina Double Wall Glasses (Set of 2, 12oz)

The right cup — a warmed demitasse for espresso, double-wall glass for milk drinks — is a small, satisfying finish to a good setup.

$35.83Buy
Take it with you
Zojirushi Stainless Steel Mug 16oz
Zojirushi

Stainless Steel Mug 16oz

A vacuum-insulated mug keeps your coffee hot for hours and doesn't leak in a bag.

$28.99Buy

Alternatives to consider

All coffee syrups
Torani Sugar Free Café Variety 4-Pack
8.0
Torani Researched

Sugar Free Café Variety 4-Pack

Four full-size sugar-free bottles, caramel, vanilla, hazelnut and chocolate, at about 32 cents a serving: the cheapest way to try sugar-free syrup across the core flavors.

Cutting sugarDaily flavored coffee
Jordan's Skinny Mixes Sugar Free Coffee Syrup Sampler, 6-Pack
7.8
Jordan's Skinny Mixes Researched

Sugar Free Coffee Syrup Sampler, 6-Pack

Six full-size sugar-free bottles, including mocha and butter toffee, at about 40 cents a serving: the widest sugar-free spread on this page.

Most sugar-free flavors in one boxHouseholds with different tastes
DaVinci Gourmet Sugar-Free Vanilla Syrup, 25.4 oz
7.2
DaVinci Gourmet Researched

Sugar-Free Vanilla Syrup, 25.4 oz

A full 750 ml bottle of sugar-free vanilla for $7.99, about 32 cents a serving: the cheapest way onto this page and the cheapest way to find out whether sucralose suits you.

Testing sugar-free syrup cheaplyVanilla lattes