OXO Brew 9-Cup vs Bonavita Connoisseur
Short answer: Buy the OXO if you want to wake up to coffee already brewed; buy the Bonavita if you want the least to think about and to spend less. Both are SCA-certified drip machines with a stainless thermal carafe, and both brew in the correct window: OXO states 197.6–204.8°F and Bonavita 194–205°F. The OXO Brew 9-Cup adds a programmable wake-up timer, a Rainmaker showerhead and a Pause & Pour feature. The Bonavita Connoisseur (BV1901TS) runs from a single button, adds an optional pre-infusion mode, and uses a flat-bottom basket.
Updated
Part of our guide to the best coffee makers.
Head to headHighest overall score: OXO Brew 9-Cup (8.6 vs 8.5) — but pick by how you brew.
 |  | |
|---|---|---|
| Score | 8.6/ 10 Higher | 8.5/ 10 |
| Price | $229.99approx.Checked 2026-10-09 | $189.95approx.Checked 2026-10-09 |
| Get it for | wake-up timer, brew & temperature score | simplest, pre-infusion (bloom), lowest price |
| Certification | SCA Golden Cup | SCA Golden Cup |
| Carafe | Double-wall thermal | Stainless thermal |
| Capacity | 9 cups | 4–8 cups (up to 44 oz) |
| AmazonFull review of OXO Brew 9-Cup | AmazonFull review of Bonavita Connoisseur 8-Cup One-Touch Coffee Maker |
Prices are approximate; use the listing for the current offer.
What the extra money buys — The OXO costs a little more than the Bonavita at current prices, and both are SCA certified with a thermal carafe. The extra buys the programmable wake-up timer, a freshness timer and Pause & Pour, plus a two-year warranty in OXO's manual. It does not buy a better-tasting pot: the Bonavita gives up the timer but adds a pre-infusion mode and one-button simplicity.
Approximate — verify the latest price
BrewSift earns a commission on some purchases. It never changes our scores. Why you can trust us
Approximate — verify the latest price
BrewSift earns a commission on some purchases. It never changes our scores. Why you can trust us
OXO Brew 9-Cup vs Bonavita Connoisseur: which wins for you
A single dial sets the clock and an automatic wake-up timer, so coffee is ready when you are. The Bonavita has no timer.
One button and a certified brew, with no menus to learn. It scores 88 for ease of use here against the OXO's 86.
An optional pre-infusion mode wets the grounds first so fresh coffee can degas before the full brew.
Costs less at current prices for the same SCA certification and a thermal carafe.
It scores 88 for brew quality and 86 for temperature control here, against 86 and 84. OXO holds 197.6–204.8°F.
OXO Brew 9-Cup vs Bonavita Connoisseur: score by dimension
BrewSift sub-scores for drip. The longer bar wins each row; equal scores are both highlighted.
OXO Brew 9-Cup vs Bonavita Connoisseur: specs side by side
OXO Brew 9-Cup vs Bonavita Connoisseur: the bottom line
Buy the OXO if you want to wake up to coffee already brewed; buy the Bonavita if you want the least to think about and to spend less. If you just want the stronger all-rounder, the OXO Brew 9-Cup edges it on our overall score (8.6 vs 8.5).
More comparisons in coffee makers
Other matchups we have run side by side, same scoring, same spec sheet.
Common questions
Is the Bonavita or the OXO coffee maker better?
They are closer than their prices suggest. Both are SCA certified, both brew into a stainless thermal carafe, and they score within a point or two of each other here. Choose the OXO Brew 9-Cup if you want a programmable wake-up timer; choose the Bonavita Connoisseur if you want one-button simplicity, a pre-infusion mode and a lower price.
Does the Bonavita Connoisseur have a timer?
No. The Connoisseur (BV1901TS) runs from a single button with no clock or delayed start. If you want coffee ready when you wake up, the OXO is the one: its dial sets the clock and an automatic wake-up timer, and a freshness timer counts up once the brew is done.
Which brews hotter?
Both brew inside the range the SCA recommends. OXO states its BetterBrew system holds water between 197.6°F and 204.8°F. Bonavita rates the Connoisseur at 194–205°F. The OXO scores a little higher for temperature control here, 86 against 84, but the difference in the cup is small.
How much coffee does each make?
About the same. OXO's manual counts 5 oz cups and tops out at 9 cups, or 45 oz of water. The Bonavita is rated for 4 to 8 cups, up to 44 oz, and Bonavita states a full 8-cup pot in about six minutes. Both are sized for a household rather than a single mug.
What is the pre-infusion mode on the Bonavita?
It wets the grounds briefly before the full brew starts, the same bloom step you would do by hand for pour-over, letting fresh coffee release gas so the water extracts it more evenly. It is optional on the Connoisseur. OXO does not advertise a separate pre-infusion setting; it adjusts brewing time by batch size instead.
Which filters do they use?
The OXO takes #4 cone-shaped paper filters, per its manual. The Bonavita uses a flat-bottom basket, built for even extraction. Buy the right shape for whichever you choose, because cone and flat-bottom filters are not interchangeable.
Is the Bonavita reliable?
It is the question worth asking. Amazon owners average 3.9 stars across more than 10,000 ratings on the shared Connoisseur listing, a mixed score for a well-regarded brewer, so the low-star reviews are worth reading for failure patterns. OXO backs its Brew appliances with a two-year warranty, per its manual.
OXO Brew 9-Cup
$229.99