Takeya vs OXO Compact Cold Brew Maker
Two popular immersion cold brew makers that solve the mess differently. The Takeya is an airtight, leak-proof pitcher you can steep on its side and even shake to speed the brew, making it the most fridge-flexible and the cheapest. The OXO Compact uses a one-switch release valve to drain the finished concentrate straight into a carafe, leaving the grounds behind for the tidiest cleanup. Pick the Takeya to save space and money; pick the OXO for the cleanest, most hands-off draining.
Get it for fridge flexibility, lowest price.
Approximate — verify the latest price
BrewSift earns a commission on some purchases. It never changes our scores. Why you can trust us
Approximate — verify the latest price
BrewSift earns a commission on some purchases. It never changes our scores. Why you can trust us
Which one wins — for you
Flip one switch and the concentrate drains through the fine-mesh filter into a carafe, leaving the grounds behind — no lifting a soggy basket.
Airtight and leak-proof, so it steeps on its side to fit anywhere, and you can shake it to brew faster.
Noticeably cheaper while still making a clean, strong concentrate.
The fine stainless mesh strains a clean concentrate as it drains; the Takeya's basket lets a little more through.
Score by dimension
BrewSift sub-scores for cold brew. The longer bar wins each row.
Specs side by side
The bottom line
The right pick depends on how you brew — match the machine to your actual use case using the “which one wins” cards above. If you just want the stronger all-rounder, the OXO Compact Cold Brew Maker edges it on our overall score (8.3 vs 8.9).
Common questions
Which makes a cleaner cold brew concentrate, Takeya or OXO?
The OXO edges it for clarity. Its fine stainless-mesh filter strains the concentrate as it drains through the release valve, so you get very little sediment. The Takeya's mesh basket is also good but lets a touch more fine sediment through. Both make a clean, strong concentrate you dilute to taste; if you want the crispest cup with the least grit, the OXO has the advantage.
Can you take the Takeya cold brew maker on the go?
Yes — that's its signature feature. The Takeya is airtight and leak-proof, so unlike most cold brew pitchers it can lie on its side in a packed fridge or travel in a bag without spilling. You can also shake it to agitate the grounds and speed up extraction. The OXO is a countertop-and-fridge brewer that isn't designed to be sealed and carried around.
How much cold brew do these make?
Both are compact makers sized for personal or small-household use, producing a batch of concentrate you dilute roughly 1:1 with water or milk, so the finished drinks stretch further than the raw concentrate volume suggests. For a week of cold brew for one or two people they're well matched; if you need to brew a half-gallon at a time, a larger system like a Toddy or County Line fits better.
What coffee and ratio should I use in either one?
Use a coarse grind (like French press) and a strong ratio around 1:5 to 1:8 coffee-to-water by weight for a concentrate, steeped 12 to 18 hours in the fridge. A bold, chocolatey medium-to-dark roast works best for cold brew. Both makers strain the grounds for you, so all you do is fill, steep, and drain or pour. Our cold brew calculator gives exact grams for each maker's capacity.